The withdrawal of Israeli troops and the establishment of an international stabilisation force are key in securing long-term peace, but the plan is dangerously vague on these issuesTwo years of death and destruction in Gaza ended once Israel and Hamas signed off on Donald Trump’s 20-point peace plan. A ceasefire is in place. Humanitarian trucks have begun to roll in. Hostages and prisoners are being exchanged. Israel has begun a first-phase pullback from the territories it controls, and under Trump’s plan its troops will eventually be deployed in a buffer zone along Gaza’s land border.Given these developments – all part of the opening phase – dismissing the momentous changes in Gaza is to deny reality. There have already been disputes over the return of the bodies of Israeli hostages, but there are unresolved longer-term problems that could derail the ceasefire and imperil the rest of the Trump plan.Rajan Menon is a professor emeritus of international relations at the City College of New York and a senior research scholar at Columbia University’s Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies Continue reading...
Saturday 18 October 2025
theguardian - 22 hours ago
Trump’s peace plan is just about holding together, but may be unravelled by two unresolved issues | Rajan Menon
Latest News
‘We don’t celebrate Black creativity enough’: why the Black British book festival is bigger than ever
- theguardian Parents will be able to block Meta bots from talking to their children under new safeguards
- theguardian Labour’s housing hypocrisy: councils serve almost 200 families with no-fault eviction notices
- theguardian It could cost over €5 million for the HSE to dispose of handwash bought during the pandemic
- thejournal ‘A glimpse of genius’: what do unpublished stories found in Harper Lee’s apartment tell us about the To Kill a Mockingbird author?
- theguardian Champagne, celebs and artefacts: British Museum hosts first lavish ‘pink ball’ fundraiser
- theguardian Revealed: UK Foreign Office staff pushed for Israel trip despite suspension of trade talks
- theguardian Connolly has captured young voters attention - but will it translate to the ballot paper?
- thejournal Shows such as Stranger Things and Yellowjackets have become bloated. I’m all for the one-and-done series | Priya Elan
- theguardian Unbeaten England eye place in semi-finals but results have masked woeful batting displays | Raf Nicholson
- theguardian Benjamin Sesko is latest player damned by a pitiless conveyor belt of takes and memes | Jonathan Liew
- theguardian Modular home builder in Co Cavan closes factory, citing lack of work in Irish housing market
- thejournal Nobody Wants This: we can’t get enough of Kristen Bell and Adam Brody’s heartstopping treat of a show
- theguardian A prophetic 1933 novel has found a surprising second life – it holds lessons for us all | Charlotte Higgins
- theguardian Tim Dowling: I’m in Greece with my band and the weather’s awful … but I can’t complain
- theguardian Meera Sodha’s recipe for jacket sweet potato with smoked tofu, slaw and crispy chilli mayo | Meera Sodha recipes
- theguardian Anger at Maccabi ban shows power of sport and why fans now expect more from its leaders | Paul MacInnes
- theguardian ‘London could 100% compete with Cannes’: Aids charity UK gala debut to honour Tracey Emin
- theguardian Fox News employees expressed concerns network was intentionally aiding Trump, legal filings reveal
- theguardian ‘I like to create chaos’: David Bentley back in spotlight for charity boxing bout with Jody Morris
- theguardian Six great reads: Virginia Giuffre’s story, the truth about chatfishing, and Peter Thiel’s search for the antichrist
- theguardian From After the Hunt to the Last Dinner Party: your complete entertainment guide to the week ahead
- theguardian ‘You’re in spy territory’: how two UK nationals got tangled in a Chinese espionage row
- theguardian ‘£30 for a ready meal?!’ Do Charlie Bigham’s new dishes really beat going to a restaurant?
- theguardian Israel says it has received body of another hostage from Gaza amid dispute over handover delays
- theguardian Breathtaking, unsettling, healing: a new exhibit by Black US artists transforms Confederate monuments
- theguardian Rowe and Payne: finish line in sight for aptly named British duo rowing nonstop from Peru to Australia
- theguardian Adverts calling for Irish construction workers to return home are popping up in Australia
- thejournal Alexander Acosta said putting Epstein on trial would’ve been a gamble, transcript shows
- theguardian Men who escaped Maze Prison in the 1970s fight extradition over links to murder of policeman
- thejournal Ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans is a terrible decision – and a depressing one | Barney Ronay
- theguardian Gesualdo Passione review – six singers and four dancers deliver a mishmash with a mystical tingle
- theguardian Banners calling for Irish construction workers to return home are popping up in Australia
- thejournal Man who fought for Hamas in October 7 attack fled to US and lived in Louisiana, FBI alleges
- theguardian Jury shown hard plastic handle found near scene where Croatian man Jozip Strok was killed in Dublin
- thejournal Volodymyr Zelenskyy arrives at White House seeking US long-range missiles to target Russia
- thejournal Survivors of airstrike on alleged drug boat in Caribbean held on US navy ship, officials say
- theguardian The Guardian view on Austen and Brontë adaptations: purists may reel, but reinvention keeps classic novels alive | Editorial
- theguardian The Guardian view on Trump and the law: a restraint on the executive is morphing into its weapon | Editorial
- theguardian Former Trump advisor Bolton pleads not guilty to charges of mishandling classified information
- thejournal ‘Let the story play out’: Postecoglou defends record as Nottingham Forest pressure grows
- theguardian Donald Trump claims to be the president of peace, but at home he is fomenting civil war | Jonathan Freedland
- theguardian Man headbutts female PSNI officer in Co Tyrone and spits in face of her colleague after arrest
- thejournal Your Guardian sport weekend: Premier League returns, F1 in the US and World Cup cricket
- theguardian Playboy, fighter, golfer and wearer of a George Washington wig: Donald Trump’s best magazine covers
- theguardian Football Daily | Liverpool v Manchester United: red rivals, green goalies and transfer blues
- theguardian Taxi driver who admitted having sex with vulnerable female passenger has cab licence reinstated
- thejournal Whether you’re in the C of E or the Taliban, some convictions are simply bigoted | Letters
- theguardianHashtags:
Trump
|peace
|about
|holding
|together
|unravelled
|unresolved
|issues
|Rajan
|Menon
|
Vivienne Westwood headlining Riyadh fashion week would be against her values, says granddaughter
- theguardian‘Americans are democracy’s equivalent of second-generation wealth’: a Chinese journalist on the US under Trump
- theguardian‘We’re ripping ourselves to shreds’: with dance music bitterly divided, how far should cultural boycotts go?
- theguardian‘Frightened to get out of their cars’: Britain’s toxic race debates threaten overseas care workers
- theguardian
Close to €290,000 in both euro and sterling seized during Newry raid on cross-border crime group
- thejournal The sale of the Telegraph is not trivial matter. A mainstream media in the grip of the right is a threat to us all | Jane Martinson
- theguardian Trump’s peace plan is just about holding together, but may be unravelled by two unresolved issues | Rajan Menon
- theguardian Fifty-five child victims of online sexual abuse identified by Gardaí in the last fifteen months
- thejournal Add to playlist: Conna Haraway’s deeply detailed dub techno and the week’s best new tracks
- theguardian Sadia Kabeya: ‘Meeting other players who look like me brought me out of my shell – I can be myself now’
- theguardian Aontú scraps no confidence motion but says it ‘succeeded’ in pressuring government on scoliosis
- thejournal Britain’s colonial botany, tiny landscapes and great bohemian outlaws – the week in art
- theguardian Sons review – Bill Nighy and Imelda Staunton’s riveting showdown rescues a laborious plot
- theguardian King Charles to be first reigning English monarch in 500 years to pray publicly with pope
- theguardian Syria and Shane O’Farrell: Connolly and Humphreys pressed on key controversies in latest debate
- thejournal Maga is painting Saturday’s protests as violent treason. Prove them wrong | Judith Levine
- theguardian US cities to resist Trump’s crackdown on dissent with No Kings protests: ‘We will not be bullied’
- theguardian Climate expert: We weren t hearing about the candidates stances on climate action, so I asked them directly
- thejournal ‘Smell is a language’: Máret Ánne Sara on why Tate’s Turbine Hall whiffs of frightened reindeer
- theguardian John Bolton says he hopes to expose Trump’s ‘abuse of power’ after being indicted – US politics live
- theguardian Srian curtha ar agallaimh le Connolly ar TG4 s RTÉ RnaG mar gheall ar threoirlínte craolacháin
- thejournal ‘Teach kids internet bollocks, not my old rubbish,’ says Shakespeare: the Stephen Collins cartoon
- theguardian The best leaf blowers: 10 favourites to speed up raking – plus smart ways to reuse your fallen leaves
- theguardian Photographer Graciela Iturbide: ‘Working with my heart is the only rule – nothing else’
- theguardian Joelle Taylor: ‘I picked up The Weirdstone of Brisingamen in a swoon of nine-year-old despair’
- theguardian Three-year-old Michigan boy saves mother’s life with quick thinking after she has seizure
- theguardian US non-profits ‘lock arms’ amid Trump’s menacing of George Soros: ‘We will not be intimidated’
- theguardian Most athletes have chosen to ‘shut up and dribble’ over Gaza | Nathan Kalman-Lamb and Derek Silva
- theguardian Leonard and Hungry Paul review – this Julia Roberts-narrated comedy is the perfect antidote to modern life
- theguardian ‘The key to success is in the sky’: the Ukrainian defenders struggling to stem Russia’s air assault
- theguardian BBC Phil/Seal: Bliss, Miracle in the Gorbals/Metamorphic Variations album review – much to enjoy
- theguardian Government officials will seek to lift ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans at Aston Villa game
- theguardian Trump’s anti-truth crusade is not just an attack on facts – it’s an unravelling of the Enlightenment | Polly Toynbee
- theguardian HSE boss says he ll take Baggot Street Hospital off the market if a state body wants it for housing
- thejournal Orban to speak with Putin as Zelenskyy prepares for White House talks with Trump – Europe live
- theguardian Ministers to explore reversing ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans attending UK match after PM’s criticism – politics live
- theguardian Brian O Driscoll was guest speaker at Israel-linked cyber summit disrupted by protesters
- thejournal Botham’s beef over not enough cricket is latest broadside in ever-earlier Ashes silly season | Emma John
- theguardian The Last Dinner Party: From the Pyre review – baroque’n’roll band’s speedily released second album is overheated
- theguardian Westlife will play five nights in Dublin s 3Arena next year to kick off their world tour
- thejournal ‘What I do with my body is none of your business’: musician Beverly Glenn-Copeland on trans rights, cult stardom and living with dementia
- theguardian Extreme weather and emergencies ‘know no borders’, Taoiseach says ahead of cross-border meeting
- thejournal Sources